Hadrosauridae
The hadrosaurids come in two basic
varieties; hollow-crested and non-hollow-crested. At each of these levels, there are
several groups, but this page will not cover them, because there is quite a bit of
housekeeping to do before we get there, namely, slogging through the indeterminate
members (interestingly, once a piece of petrified wood was described as being
hadrosaurid remains [Aachenosaurus]). If you want to skip this page, I don't blame
you (although I have a soft spot for Claosaurus; it was one of the first
obscure dinosaurs I learned about, back around the late 1980s-early 1990s, from
an article in a kid's magazine about dinosaurs).
Additional basal hadrosaurid material is known from the late
Santonian (LK) of Italy, the mid Turonian (LK) of Alaska, late
Maastrichtian (LK) of Spain and possibly Antarctica. In addition, a
hadrosaurid femur discovered in New Mexico may be evidence that some dinosaurs
were able to make it into the earliest part of the Paleocene, just beyond the
K-T boundary, although most authorities consider it to have been reworked from
older sediments.
<--Hadrosauridae
|--Bactrosaurus
|--Gilmoreosaurus
`--+--Telmatosaurus
`--+--Pararhabdodon
`--Euhadrosauria
|-->Hadrosaurinae
`-->Lambeosaurinae
Hadrosauridae: Hadrosaurids were long thought to have lived in
water, another set of victims of the mindset that condemned sauropods as well to the watery
regions. In the case of hadrosaurids, they were they because they were supposedly
swimmers, as shown by their tall tails and "webbed" hands found on
"mummies," and because their teeth seemed weak However, it turned out the
tail was very inflexible due to bony tendons, and the webs of the hands were shown to be
dried-out cushions for the hands. As for the teeth, that is a patent lie.
Hadrosaurids were very well adapted to feed at low levels on land, much like bison. Their backs
even show a striking resemblance to the way bison spines are curved. The best
analogue for a hadrosaurid would have to include this low-browsing ability with a hint of
the bewildering variety of display devices hadrosaurids were equipped with. Many
hadrosaurids are known to have lived in groups, possibly not true herds, but groups
nonetheless. In fact, it has been suggested that one mass "grave" of Maiasaura
contains the remains of a gathering 10,000 individuals strong.
Hadrosaurids show some sort of unusual midline
spinal phenomenon. Some appear to have dragon-like rectangular nonbony segments
running down the midline of the back, while others suggest a deep, horse-like muscular
neck. Hadrosaurids appear to have had rather thin, leathery skin, with large
polygonal or oval tubercles surrounded by many smaller ones. The scale
patterns may have some diagnostic value.
It is an unfortunate fact that without a decent
skull, it is hard to differentiate most hadrosaurids, due to the basic overall
similarity of the skeletal plan. Lambeosaurines can be told from hadrosaurines in
some elements, such as the hip bones and height of the neural spines (many lambeosaurines
have slight "sails" down the back), but that is about as far as one can go with
separating hadrosaurids from postcranial material at this point; people are
looking for differentiating characters, though. Ceratopids
have a similar problem, but probably worse, as the frill is necessary as
everything else is pretty much the same across taxa, and the frill didn't come
in until the animal was nearly an adult.
| Taxon or Taxa: | Time\Place: | Comments: | |
| Bactrosaurus johnsoni Gilmore, 1933 | early Maastrichtian (LK) of China | Bactrosaurus is one of the most basal hadrosaurids. It is known from partial skeletons belonging to robust individuals. According to the common interpretation, at the time of describing an iguanodont-like skull got mixed in with the remains and made an animal with a classic lambeosaurine postcranium into a hadrosaurine. Later, it was discovered that two hadrosaurids were represented in the remains, one being the lambeosaurine Bactrosaurus, the other (and the owner of the skull) a hadrosaurine-like animal now named Gilmoreosaurus. However, some researchers are suggesting, based on further bonebed material, that Bactrosaurus was not chimeric and the flat skull actually a part of one individual (but still separated from Gilmoreosaurus), making this animal not a lambeosaurine, but a more basal hadrosaurid. | |
| Gilmoreosaurus: Brett-Surman, 1979 | G. mongoliensis (type) (Gilmore, 1933 [originally Mandschurosaurus mongoliensis]) | early Maastrichtian (LK) of China | Gilmoreosaurus was long confused with
the dubious hadrosaurid Mandschurosaurus. Some material once referred to
the early hollow-crested hadrosaurid Bactrosaurus, appears to actually belong to the contemporaneous Gilmoreosaurus
instead, which has a more gracile body. G. arkhangelski may be chimeric. |
| ?G. arkhangelskyi (?N.D.) Nessov, 1995 | late Turonian-Coniacian (LK) of Uzbekistan | ||
| Pararhabdodon isonensis Casanovas-Cladellas, Santafe-Llopis, and Isidoro Llorens, 1993 | Maastrichtian (LK) of Spain and ?France | Pararhabdodon was originally described as a basal iguanodontian somewhat like Rhabdodon, then as a small lambeosaurine. A thorough restudy suggests it is a basal hadrosaurid close to the hadrosaurine-lambeosaurine split. | |
| Telmatosaurus transsylvanicus Nopcsa, 1903 (originally Limnosaurus transsylvanicus Nopcsa, 1900) | early-mid Maastrichtian (LK) of Romania, France, and Spain | This possible basal hadrosaurid (position currently uncertain) is very similar to Iguanodon and its ilk. It is known from 5 to 10 fragmentary skulls, plus some postcranial material. | |
Hadrosauridae i.s.:
| Taxon or Taxa: | Time\Place: | Comments: | |
| Cionodon arctatus (N.D.) Cope, 1874 (?Thespesius) | late Maastrichtian (LK) of Colorado | This indeterminate hadrosaurid is based on a maxilla, two dorsals, partial third metatarsal, and the ends of an ulna. | |
| "Cionodon": | "C." kysylkumensis (N.D.) Riabinin, 1931 | upper Turonian-Coniacian (LK) of Uzbekistan | This animal may be some sort of basal hadrosaurid. |
| "C." stenopsis (N.D.) Cope, 1875 | late middle Campanian (LK) of Alberta | This is an anonymous indeterminate hadrosaurid from the early days of North American dinosaur research, based on part of a maxilla. | |
| Claosaurus agilis Marsh, 1890 (originally Hadrosaurus agilis, Marsh, 1872) | mid Santonian-early Campanian (LK) of Kansas | Based on a mostly complete postcranium, Claosaurus is one of the most primitive hadrosaurids. However, this is a good place to explode the myth of it retaining the first metatarsal, which all other hadrosaurids for which the foot is known have lost. There was no MT I! | |
| "Claosaurus" affinis (N.D.) Wieland, 1903 | early Campanian (LK) of South Dakota | This animal is based on a now-missing toe bone. | |
| Diclonius: (N.D.) Cope, 1876 | D. pentagonus (N.D.) (type) Cope, 1876 | late middle Campanian (LK) of Montana | Because the teeth (and one partial lower jaw, from D. pentagonus) these various species are based on all came from the same area, they are retained in Diclonius. They may very well all belong to the same animal, or from a collection of Judith River hadrosaurids. |
| D. calamarius (N.D.) Cope, 1876 | |||
| D. perangulatus (N.D.) Cope, 1876 | |||
| "Hadrosaurus": | "H." breviceps (N.D.) Marsh, 1889 | late middle Campanian (LK) of Montana | This is just another indeterminate hadrosaurid, possibly the same as Prosaurolophus, although it has been referred to Kritosaurus (in the guise of Gryposaurus) in the past. It is based on part of a dentary. |
| "H." cavatus (N.D.) Cope, 1871 | late Campanian-early Maastrichtian (LK) of New Jersey | These two species may well be the same thing. "H." cavatus is based on caudal vertebrae, "H." minor on dorsals, with referred material comprised of a partial hindlimb, verts, ribs, and hips. The [currently missing] ischia are described as unexpanded, possibly indicating a hadrosaurine. | |
| "H." minor (N.D.) Marsh, 1870 | late Campanian-early Maastrichtian (LK) of New Jersey | ||
| "Hironosaurus" (N.N.) Hisa, 1988 | LK of Japan | "Hironosaurus" has yet to be described. | |
| Hypsibema crassicauda (N.D.) Cope, 1869 | Campanian (LK) of North Carolina | Hypsibema is a gigantic hadrosaurid based on caudals, a partial humerus, a partial tibia, and a partial metatarsal. It is sometimes synonymized with "Neosaurus," another giant hadrosaurid from the eastern part of the United States, but given the limited remains, I don't find that justified. The original material also mixed in a theropod femur for good measure. | |
| "Iguanodon" hilli (N.D.) Newton, 1892 | Cenomanian (LK) of England | A rare European hadrosaurid, this is also one of the earliest known hadrosaurids. | |
| "Jaxartosaurus" fuyunensis (N.D.) Wu, 1984 | LK of China | This indeterminate hadrosaurid could possibly be a lambeosaurine. | |
| Koutalisaurus kohlerorum Prieto-Marquez, Gaete, Rivas, Galobart, and Boada, 2006 | Maastrichtian (LK) of Spain | Koutalisaurus is based on a distinctive dentary that is steeply curved inward and down, giving it a spoon-shaped jaw. The type had been referred to the contemporaneous Pararhabdodon. | |
| ?"Mandschurosaurus" laosensis (N.D.) Hoffet, 1943 | Coniacian-Maastrichtian (LK) of Laos | This animal may not even be a hadrosaurid. | |
| Microhadrosaurus nanshuingensis (N.D.) Dong, 1979 | early Maastrichtian (LK) of China | Based on a small dentary, this is most probably a juvenile hadrosaurid. | |
| "Neosaurus" missouriensis (N.D.) Gilmore and Stewart, 1945 (Parrosaurus) | ?early Maastrichtian (LK) of Missouri | This dubious giant hadrosaurid may masquerade as either Parrosaurus (because Neosaurus was preoccupied) or as Hypsibema missouriensis (or even H. crassicauda, as I used to have it); as the latter, it is most commonly seen, and has become the official state dinosaur of Missouri. "Neosaurus" is based on caudals and a partial lower jaw, at first thought to belong to a camarasaurid-like sauropod because of their large size. | |
| Ornithotarsus immanis (N.D.) Cope, 1869 (?Hadrosaurus) | Campanian (LK) of New Jersey | Sometimes synonymized with Hadrosaurus, this animal is based on a partial hindlimb of a very large individual. | |
| ?Orthomerus dolloi (N.D.) Seeley, 1883 | Maastrichtian (LK) of the Netherlands | Often considered the same as Telmatosaurus in older works, this animal may not even be a hadrosaurid. | |
| "Orthomerus" weberi (N.D.) Riabinin, 1945 | Maastrichtian (LK) of Ukraine | "O." weberi is based on hindlimb bits. | |
| "Saurolophus" kryschtofovici (N.D.) Riabinin, 1930 | early Maastrichtian (LK) of China | This species, usually synonymized with Saurolophus angustirostris, is based on a fragmentary partial ischium. | |
| Secernosaurus koerneri Brett-Surman, 1979 | late Cenomanian-early Turonian (LK) of Argentina | Secernosaurus was the first hadrosaurid described from South America. Beyond that, the limited remains have not yet offered much information. | |
| Tanius sinensis Wiman, 1929 | early-mid Maastrichtian (LK) of China | Considered at times to be congeneric with Tsintaosaurus, this obscure and mysterious hadrosaurid is known from ?three disarticulated specimens. At times it has been classified as a basal hadrosaurid, although it my have lambeosaurine affinities. | |
| Thespesius occidentalis (N.D.) Leidy, 1856 | late Maastrichtian (LK) of South Dakota | This indeterminate hadrosaurid used to get a lot more play (if you go back in the literature, a bunch of species now referred to Edmontosaurus were put here). It is based on caudals and a pedal phalanx. | |
| Trachodon mirabilis (N.D.) Leidy, 1856 | late middle Campanian (LK) of Montana and Alberta | Made famous in countless cheesy children's toys, Trachodon is actually a fraud, a dubious tooth taxon. In fact, of the type teeth, some belong to a ceratopid, and others to a hadrosaurid. The name today is usually restricted to the hadrosaurid teeth, which may have come from an animal like Corythosaurus. | |
| "Trachodon": | "T." altidens (N.D.) Lambe, 1902 | late middle Campanian (LK) of Alberta | Based on a partial maxilla, this specimen has been mooted as a "procheneosaur", which for our purposes means a juvenile lambeosaurine, which it may well be. |
| "T." amurensis (N.D.) Riabinin, 1925 | early-mid Maastrichtian (LK) of China, ?Coniacian-?Maastrichtian (LK) of Russia | Better known as Mandschurosaurus, this is based on a large, very fragmentary skeleton of a generalized hadrosaurid, that doesn't have a well-preserved skull, almost a death sentence for hadrosaurid taxa, as they often can only be told apart by their skulls. New material is apparently known, though. | |
| "T." cantabrigiensis (N.D.) Lydekker, 1888 | late Albian (EK) of England | This is a very early indeterminate hadrosaurid, mostly known for popping up in discussions of early hadrosaurids as a possible example. | |
| "T." marginatus (N.D.) Lambe, 1902 | late middle Campanian (LK) of Alberta | This collection of postcranial remains and teeth has sometimes been referred to Kritosaurus (as Gryposaurus), although a chunk of it has ended up in Lambeosaurus. It probably represents Gryposaurus. | |
| "T." selwyni (N.D.) Lambe, 1902 | This species is based on a lower jaw with teeth, the latter most like those from "Hadrosaurus" breviceps. It seems to be most like Gryposaurus and Lambeosaurus. | ||
| ?"Troodon" isfarensis (N.D.) Nessov, 1995 | early Santonian (LK) of Tajikistan | This was described as a troodontid based on a frontal (currently missing), but more recent study using the description and photograph of the bone suggests that it was really a hadrosaurid based on a prefrontal. | |
| Zhuchengosaurus maximus Zhao X., Li D., Han G., Hao H., Liu F., Li L., and Fang X., 2007 | EK-LK boundary, China | This hadrosaurid, from rocks about 100 million years old, is known from remains of several individuals. It is the largest described hadrosaurid, with a composite mount 16.6 meters long. It appears to be flat-headed. | |
Hadrosaurinae and Lambeosaurinae: These two groups are the derived hadrosaurids. They have some of the best fossil records of any dinosaurs, with skulls and skeletons known for most taxa.
| Navigation | ||
| Home Page | Alphabetical Dinosaur Index | Clado-Index |
| Background Information | Glossary | Faunae |