on
CHRISTIANITY AND SOCIAL PROGRESS
(Mater et Magistra)
May 15, 1961
THE TRIPLE CROWN
OR TIARA
THE POPE'S OFFICIAL HEADDRESS
To Our Venerable Brothers, the Patriarchs,
Primates, Archbishops, Bishops and Other
Local Ordinaries in Peace and Communion
with the Holy See, and to all the Clergy and
Faithful of the Catholic World
On Recent Developments of the Social Question
in the Light of Christian Teaching
Venerable Brothers and Dear Sons:
Health and Apostolic Benediction
The Catholic Church has been established by Jesus
Christ as Mother and Teacher of nations, so that all who in the
course of centuries come to her loving embrace, may find salvation as well
as the fullness of a more excellent life. To this Church, "the pillar
and mainstay of the truth," (Cf. I Tim. 3, 15.)
her most Holy Founder has entrusted the double task of begetting sons unto
herself, and of educating and governing those whom she begets, guiding
with maternal providence the life both of individuals and of peoples.
The lofty dignity of this life, she has always held in the highest respect
and guarded with watchful care.
2. For the teaching of Christ joins,
as it were, earth with Heaven, in that it embraces the whole man, namely,
his soul and body, intellect and will, and bids him to lift up his mind
from the changing conditions of human existence to that Heavenly country
where he will one day enjoy unending happiness and peace.
3. Hence, although Holy Church has the
special task of sanctifying souls and of making them sharers of Heavenly
blessings, she is also solicitous for the requirements of men in their
daily lives, not merely those relating to food and sustenance, but also
to their comfort and advancement in various kinds of goods and in varying
circumstances of time.
4. Realizing all this, Holy Church implements
the commands of her Founder, Christ, Who refers primarily to man's eternal
salvation when He says, "I am the Way, and the Truth, and the Life" (John
14, 6.) and elsewhere "I am the Light of the World." (John
8, 12.) On other occasions, however, seeing the hungry
crowd, He was moved to exclaim sorrowfully, "I have compassion on the crowd,"
(Mark 8, 2.) thereby indicating that He was
also concerned about the earthly needs of mankind. The Divine Redeemer
shows this care not only by His words but also by the actions of His life,
as when, to alleviate the hunger of the crowds, He more than once miraculously
multiplied bread.
5. By this bread, given for the nourishment
of the body, He wished to foreshadow that heavenly food of the soul which
He was to give to men on the day before He suffered.
6. It is no wonder, then, that the Catholic
Church, instructed by Christ and fulfilling His commands, has for two thousand
years, from the Ministry of the early Deacons to the present time, tenaciously
held aloft the torch of Charity not only by her teaching but also by her
widespread example--that Charity which, by combining in a fitting manner
the precepts and the practice of mutual love, puts into effect in a wonderful
way this twofold commandment of giving, wherein is contained the full social
teaching and action of the Church.
7. By far the most notable evidence
of this social teaching and action, which the Church has set forth through
the centuries, undoubtedly is the very distinguished Encyclical Letter
Rerum
Novarun, (Acta Leonis XIII, XI [1891], P.
97-144.) issued seventy years ago by our predecessor of immortal
memory, Leo XIII. Therein he put forward teachings whereby the question
of the workers' condition would be resolved in conformity with Christian
principles.
8. Seldom have the admonitions of a Pontiff
been received with such universal approbation, as was that Encyclical of
Leo XIII, rivaled by few in the depth and scope of its reasoning and in
the forcefulness of its expression. Indeed, the norms and recommendations
contained therein were so momentous that their memory will never fall into
oblivion. As a result, the action of the Catholic Church became more
widely known. For its Supreme Pastor, making his own the problems
of weak and harassed men, their complaints and aspirations, had devoted
himself especially to the defense and restoration of their rights.
9. Even today, in spite of the long
lapse of time since the Letter was published, much of its effectiveness
is still evident. It is indeed evident in the documents of the Popes
who succeeded Leo XIII, and who, when they discussed economic and social
affairs, have always borrowed something from it, either to clarify its
application or to stimulate further activity on the part of Catholics.
The efficacy of the document also is evident in the laws and institutions
of many nations. Thus does it become abundantly clear that the solidly
grounded principles, the norms of action, and the paternal admonitions
found in the masterly Letter of our predecessor, even today retain their
original worth. Moreover, from it can be drawn new and vital criteria,
whereby men may judge the nature and extent of the social question, and
determine what their responsibilities are in this regard.
PART I
TEACHINGS OF THE ENCYCLICAL
"RERUM NOVARUM" AND TIMELY
DOCTRINAL DEVELOPMENTS
DURING THE PONTIFICATES OF
PIUS XI AND PIUS XII
The Period of the Encyclical, "Rerum Novarum"
10. The teachings addressed to mankind
by this most wise Pontiff undoubtedly shone with greater brilliance because
they were published when innumerable difficulties obscured the issue.
On the one hand, the economic and political situation was in process of
radical change; on the other, numerous clashes were flaring up and civil
strife had been provoked.
11. As is generally known, in those
days an opinion widely prevailed and was commonly put into practice, according
to which, in economic matters, everything was to be attributed to inescapable,
natural forces. Hence, it was held that no connection existed between
economic and moral laws. Wherefore, those engaged in economic activity
need look no further than their own gain. Consequently, mutual relations
between economic agents could be left to the play of free and unregulated
competition. Interest on capital, prices of goods and services, profits
and wages, were to be determined purely mechanically by the laws of the
marketplace. Every precaution was to be taken lest the civil authority
intervene in any way in economic affairs. During that era, trade
unions, according to circumstances in diffferent countries, were sometimes
forbidden, sometimes tolerated, sometimes recognized in private law.
12. Thus, at that time, not only was
the proud rule of the stronger regarded as legitimate, so far as economic
affairs were concerned, but it also prevailed in concrete relations between
men. Accordingly, the order of economic affairs was, in general,
radically disturbed.
13. While a few accumulated excessive
riches, large masses of workingmen daily labored in very acute need.
Indeed, wages were insufficient for the necessities of life, and sometimes
were at starvation level. For the most part, workers had to find
employment under conditions wherein there were dangers to health, moral
integrity, and religious faith. Especially inhuman were the working
conditions to which children and women were subjected. The spectre
of unemployment was ever present, and the family was exposed to a process
of disorganization.
14. As a natural consequence, workers,
indignant at their lot, decided that this state of affairs must be publicly
protested. This explains why, among the working classes, extremist
theories that propounded remedies worse than the evil to be cured, found
widespread favor.
The Way to Reconstruction
15. Such being the trend of the
times, Leo. XIII, in his Encyclical Letter Rerum Novarum, proclaimed
a social message based on the requirements of human nature itself and conforming
to the precepts of the Gospel and reason. We recall it as a message
which, despite some expected opposition, evoked response on all sides and
aroused widespread enthusiasm. However, this was not the first time
the Apostolic See, in regard to the affairs of this life, undertook the
defense of the needy, since that same predecessor of happy memory, Leo
XIII, published other documents which to some extent paved the way for
the document mentioned above. But this Letter so effected for the
first time an organization of principles, and, as it were, set forth singlemindedly
a future course of action, that we may regard it as a summary of Catholic
teaching, so far as economic and social matters are concerned.
16. It can be said with considerable
assurance that such proved to be the situation. For while some, confronted
with the social question, unashamedly attacked the Church as if she did
nothing except preach resignation to the poor and exhort the rich to generosity,
Leo XIII did not hesitate to proclaim and defend quite openly the sacred
rights of workers. In beginning his exposition of the principles
and norms of the Church in social matters, he frankly stated: "We
approach the subject with confidence and in the exercise of the rights
that belong to us. For no satisfactory solution of this question
will ever be found without the assistance of Religion and the Church."
(Ibid.
p.
107.)
17. Venerable Brothers, you are quite
familiar with those basic principles expounded both clearly and authoritatively
by the illustrious Pontiff, according to which human society should be
renewed in so far as economic and social matters are concerned.
18. He first and foremost stated that
work, inasmuch as it is an expression of the human person, can by no means
be regarded as a mere commodity. For the great majority of mankind,
work is the only source from which the means of livelihood are drawn. Hence,
its remuneration is not to be thought of in terms of merchandise, but rather
according to the laws of justice and equity. Unless this is done,
justice is violated in labor agreements, even though they are entered into
freely on both sides.
19. Private property, including that
of productive goods, is a natural right possessed by all, which the State
may by no means suppress. However, as there is from nature a social
aspect to private property, he who uses his right in this regard must take
into account not merely his own welfare but that of others as well.
20. The State, whose purpose is
the realization of the common good in the temporal order, can by no
means disregard the economic activity of its citizens. Indeed, it
should be present to promote in a suitable manner the production of a sufficient
supply of material goods, "the use of which is necessary for the practice
of virtues." (St. Thomas, De regimine principum,
I,
15.) Moreover, it should safeguard the rights of all citizens,
but especially the weaker, such as workers, women, and children.
Nor may the State ever neglect its duty to contribute actively to the betterment
of the living conditions of workers.
21. In addition, the State should see
to it that labor agreements are entered into according to the norms of
justice and equity, and that in the environment of work the dignity
of the human being is not violated either in body or spirit. On
this point, Leo XIII's Letter delineated the broad principles regarding
a just and proper human existence. These principles, modern States
have adopted in one way or another in their social legislation, and they
have--as our predecessor of immortal memory, Pius XI declared, in his Encyclical
Letter, Quadragesimo Anno (Acta Apostolicae
Sedis, XXIII [1931]. p. 185.) --contributed much to the establishment
and promotion of that new section of legal science known as labor law.
22. In the same Letter, moreover, there
is affirmed the natural right to enter corporately into associations, whether
these be composed of workers only or of workers and management; and also
the right to adopt that organizational structure judged more suitable to
meet their professional needs. And workers themselves have the right
to act freely and on their own initiative within the above-mentioned associations,
without hindrance and as their needs dictate.
23. Workers and employers should regulate
their mutual relations in a spirit of human solidarity and in accordance
with the bond of Christian brotherhood. For the unregulated competition
which so-called liberals espouse, or the class struggle in the Marxist
sense, are utterly opposed to Christian teaching and also to the very
nature of man.
24. These, Venerable Brothers,
are the fundamental prinicples on which a healthy socio-economic order
can be built.
25. It is not surprising, therefore,
that outstanding Catholic men inspired by these appeals began many activities
in order to put these principles to action. Nor were there lacking
other men of good will in various parts of the world who, impelled by the
needs of human nature, followed a similar course.
26. For these reasons the Encyclical
is known even to the present day as the Magna Charta (Cf.
Ibid.,
p.
189.) for the reconstruction of the economic and social order.
The Encyclical "Quadragesimo Anno"
27. Furthermore, after a lapse of forty
years since publication of that outstanding corpus, as it were, of directives,
our predecessor of happy memory, Pius XI, in his turn decided to publish
the Encyclical Letter Quadragesimo Anno. (Ivid.,
p.
177-228.)
28. In it the Supreme Pontiff first
of all confirmed the right and duty of the Catholic Church to make its
special contribution in resolving the more serious problems of society
which call of the full cooperation of all. Then he reaffirmed those
principles and directives of Leo XIII's Letter related to the conditions
of the times. Finally, he took this occasion not only to clarify
certain points of Doctrine on which even Catholics were in doubt, but
he also showed how the principles and directives themselves regarding social
affairs should be adapted to the changing times.
29. For at that time, some were in doubt
as to what should be the judgment of Catholics regarding private property,
the wage system, and more especially, a type of moderate socialism.
30. Concerning private property, our
predecessor reaffirmed its natural-law character. Furthermore, he
set forth clearly and emphasized the social character and function of private
ownership.
31. Turning to the wage system, after
having rejected the view that would declare it unjust by its very nature,
the Pontiff criticized the inhuman and unjust forms under which it was
sometimes found. Moreover, he carefully indicated what norms and
conditions were to be observed, lest the wage system stray from justice
and equity.
32. In this connection, it is today
advisable as our predecessor clearly pointed out, that work agreements
be tempered in certain respects with partnership arrangements, so that
"workers and officials become participants in ownership, or management,
or share in some manner in profits." (Cf. Ibid., p.
199.)
33. Of great theoretical and practical
importance is the affirmation of Pius XI that "if the social and individual
character of labor be overlooked, the efficency of men can neither be justly
appraised nor equitably recompensed." (Cf. Ibid., p.
200.) Accordingly, in determining wages, justice definitely
requires that, in addition to the needs of the individual worker and his
family, regard be had on the one hand for conditions within the productive
enterprises wherein the workers labor; on the other hand, for the "public
econimic good" (Cf. Ibid., p. 201.) in
general.
34. Furthermore, the Supreme Bishop
emphasized that the views of communists, as they are called, and
of Christians are radically opposed. Nor may Catholics, in any way,
give approbation to the teachings of socialists who seemingly profess
more moderate views. From their basic outlook it follows that,
inasmuch as the order of social life is confined to time, it is directed
solely to temporal welfare; that since the social relationships of men
pertain merely to the production of goods, human liberty is excessively
restricted and the true concept of social authority is overlooked.
35. Pius XI was not unaware that, in
the forty years that had elapsed since the appearance of Leo XIII's Letter,
historical conditions had profoundly altered. In fact, unrestricted
competition, because of its own inherent tendencies, had ended by almost
destroying itself. It had caused a great accumulation of wealth
and a corresponding concentration of power in the hands of a few
who "are frequently not the owners, but only the trustees and directors
of invested funds, who administer them at their good pleasure." (Cf.
Ibid.,
p.
210f.)
36. Therefore, as the Supreme Pontiff
noted, "economic power has been substituted for the free marketplace.
Unbridled ambition for domination has replaced desire for gain; the whole
economy has become harsh, cruel, and relentless in frightful measure."
(Cf. Ibid., p. 211.) Thus it happened
that even public authorities were serving the interests of more wealthy
men and that concentrations of wealth, to some extent, achieved power over
all peoples.
37. In opposition to this trend, the
Supreme Pontiff laid down the following fundamental principles: the
organization of economic affairs must be conformable to practical morality;
the interests of individuals or of societies especially must be harmonized
with the requirements of the common good. This evidently requires,
as the teaching of our predecessor indicated, the orderly reorganization
of society with smaller professional and economic groups existing in their
own right, and not prescribed by public authority. In the next place,
civil authority should reassume its function and not overlook any of the
community's interests. Finally, on a world-wide scale, governments
should seek the economic good of all peoples.
38. The two fundamental points that
especially characterize the Encyclical of Pius XI are these: First,
one may not take as the ultimate criteria in economic life the interests
of individuals or organized groups, nor unregulated competition, nor excessive
power on the part of the wealthy, nor the vain honor of the nation or its
desire for domination, nor anything of this sort.
39. Rather, it is necessary that
economic undertakings be governed by justice and charity as the principal
laws of social life.
40. The second point that we
consider to be basic to the Letter of Piux XI is that both within individual
countries and among nations there be established a juridical order, with
appropriate public and private institutions, inspired by social justice,
so that those who are involved in economic activities are enabled to carry
out their tasks in conformity with the common good.
Radio Broadcast of Pentecost, 1941
41. In specifying social rights and
obligations, our predecessor of immortal memory, Pius XII, made a significant
contribution, when on the feast of Pentecost, June 1, 1941, he broadcast
to the world community a message: "In order to call to the attention
of the Catholic world the memory of an event worthy of being written in
letters of gold on the Calendar of the Church: namely, the fiftieth anniversary
of the publication of the epoch-making Encyclical of Leo XIII, Rerum
Novarun." (Cf. Acta Apostolicae Sedia, XXXIII
[1941], p. 196.) He broadcast this message, moreover, "to
render special thanks to Almighty God that His Vicar on earth, in a Letter
such as this, gave to the Church so great a gift, and also to render praise
to the eternal Spirit that through this same Letter, He enkindled a fire
calculated to rouse the whole human race to new and better effort." (Cf.
Ibid.,
p.
197.)
42. In the message, the great Pontiff
claimed for the Church "the indisputable competence" to "decide whether
the bases of a given social system are in accord with the unchangeable
order which God our Creator and Redeemer has fixed both in the natural
law and revelation." (Cf. Ibid., p. 196.) He
noted that the Letter of Leo XIII is of permanent value and has
rich and abiding usefulness. He takes the occasion "to explain
in greater detail what the Catholic Church teaches regarding the three
principal issues of social life in economic affairs, which are mutually
related and connected one with the other, and thus interdependent: namely,
the use of material goods, labor, and the family." (Cf. Ibid.,
p.
198f.)
43. Concerning the use of material goods,
our predecessor declared that the right of every man to use them for his
own sustenance is prior to all other rights in economic life, and hence
is prior even to the right of private ownership. It is certain, however,
as our predecessor noted, that the right of private property is from the
natural law itself. Nevertheless, it is the will of God the Creator
that this right to own property should in no wise obstruct the flow of
"material goods created by God to meet the needs of all men, to all equitably,
as justice and charity require." (Cf. Ibid., p. 199.)
44. As regards labor, Pius XII repeating
what appeared in Leo XIIII's Letter, declared it to be both a duty and
a right of every human being. Consequently, it is in the first place
the responsibility of men themselves to regulate mutual labor relations.
Only in the event that the interested parties are unwilling or unable to
fulfill their functions, does it "devolve upon the State to intervene and
to assign labor equitably, safeguarding the standards and aims that the
common good properly understood demands." (Cf. Ibid.,
p.
201.)
45. Turning to the family, the Supreme
Pontiff stresses that private ownership of material goods helps to safeguard
and develop family life. Such goods are an apt means "to secure for
the father of a family the healthy liberty he needs in order to fulfill
the duties assigned him by the Creator, regarding the physical, spiritual,
and religious welfare of the family." (Cf. Ibid., p.
202.) From this arises the right of the family to migrate.
Accordingly, our predecessor reminds governments, both those permitting
emigration and those accepting immigrants, that "they never permit anything
whereby mutual and sincere understanding between States is diminished or
destroyed." (Cf. Ibid., p. 203.) If this
be mutually accomplished, it will come to pass that benefits are equalized
and diffused widely among peoples, as the supply of goods and the arts
and crafts are increased and fostered.
Further Changes
46. But just as contemporary circumstances
seemed to Pius XII quite dissimilar from those of the earlier period, so
they have changed greatly over the past twenty years. This can be
seen not only in the internal situation of each individual country, but
also in the mutual relations of countries.
47. In the fields of science, technology,
and economics, these developments are especially worthy of note: the discovery
of atomic energy, employed first for military purposes and later increasingly
for peaceful ends; the almost limitless possibilities opened up by chemistry
in synthetic products; the growth of automation in the sectors of industry
and services; the modernization of agriculture; the nearly complete conquest,
especially through radio and television, of the distance separating peoples;
the greatly increased speed of all manner of transportation; the initial
conquests of outer space.
48. Turning to the social field, the
following contemporary trends are evident: development of systems for social
insurance; the introduction of social security systems in some more affluent
countries; greater awareness among workers, as members of unions, of the
principal issues in economic and social life; a progressive improvement
of basic education; wider diffusion among the citizenry of the conveniences
of life; increased social mobility and a resulting decline in divisions
among the classes; greater interest than heretofore in world affairs on
the part of those with average education. Meanwhile, if one considers
the social and economic advances made in a growing number of countries,
he will quickly discern increasingly pronounced imbalances: first, between
agriculture on the one hand and industry and the services on the other;
between the more and the less developed regions within countries; and,
finally, on a worldwide scale, between countries with differing economic
resources and development.
49. Turning now to political affairs,
it is evident that there, too, a number of innovations have occurred.
Today, in many communities, citizens from almost all social strata participate
in public life. Public authorities intervene more and more in economic
and social affairs. The peoples of Asia and Africa, having
set aside colonial systems, now govern themselves according to their own
laws and institutions. As the mutual relationships of peoples increase,
they become daily more dependent one upon the other. Throughout the
world, assemblies and councils have become more common, which, being supranational
in character, take into account the interests of all peoples. Such
bodies are concerned with economic life, or with social affairs, or with
culture and education, or, finally, with the mutual relationships of peoples.
Reasons for the New Encyclical
50. Now, reflecting on all these things,
we
feel it our duty to keep alive the torch lighted by our great predecessors
and to exhort all to draw from their writings light and inspiration,
if they wish to resolve the social question in ways more in accord with
the needs of the present time. Therefore, we are issuing
this present Letter not merely to commemorate appropriately the Encyclical
Letter of Leo XIII, but also, in the light of changed conditions, both
to confirm and explain more fully what our predecessors taught, and to
set forth the Church's teaching regarding the new and serious problems
of our day.
(Because this is such a long Encyclical Letter and in order not to make such a long file, it will be in 4 (four) files. To continue click on CONTINUE below.)